Germany’s armed forces chief has rejected the idea of a draft lottery in the ongoing debate over reintroducing military service, saying all young men should undergo assessment to determine eligibility.
General Inspector Carsten Breuer told Germany’s RND media group that, from a military standpoint, it was essential to screen entire age groups. “Only then do we know who is available and whom we could call upon in a defense situation — one we want to prevent,” he said.
Breuer argued that drawing lots after screening would bring in recruits by chance rather than motivation, making training less effective. If not enough volunteers come forward, he said the Bundeswehr should select those who are “especially qualified and motivated,” targeting skills such as IT expertise rather than relying on random selection.
He said a voluntary model would likely attract more recruits, provided that service is seen as meaningful and appealing.
The Bundestag is currently debating a new military service law. Within the ruling coalition, disagreement remains over what steps to take if voluntary enlistment fails to meet the Bundeswehr’s personnel needs.
