Skip to content
Malta's world news feed Local perspective with global outlook
CDE.NEWS The Dispatch
Comuniq.EU

MEPs say Malta’s rule of law reforms remain unfinished, call for results on corruption and justice

epa05665541 The Malta and European Union flags around the Auberge de Castille in Valletta, Malta, 08 December 2016. Malta will be hosting the European Presidency in 2017. EPA/DOMENIC AQUILINA

Malta has made progress in reforming its justice system and strengthening safeguards for journalists, but significant shortcomings remain in the fight against corruption, judicial independence and media freedom, a European Parliament delegation has concluded following a two-day visit to Valletta.

The delegation of the European Parliament’s Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs (LIBE), which visited Malta on 16 and 17 November, said reforms introduced in recent years had yet to translate into effective prosecutions for corruption and lasting institutional change.

Headed by Sophie Wilmès, the delegation’s visit followed the acquittal of the main suspect in the alleged commissioning of the murder of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia. Its discussions focused on the effectiveness of Malta’s justice system, the rule of law, anti-corruption measures and media freedom.

In its conclusions, the delegation acknowledged progress, including additional resources for the judiciary, police and prosecutors, stronger judicial safeguards, modernised court procedures and improved provisions on media freedom and transparency. However, it said the record of corruption prosecutions remained ineffective, while lengthy court proceedings and the lack of final judgments in high-level corruption cases continued to raise concerns.

MEPs also called for a reassessment of aspects of the jury system and further measures to strengthen judicial independence, including reform of the procedure for appointing the Chief Justice.

On media freedom, the delegation welcomed new safeguards protecting journalistic sources, greater transparency in media ownership and changes affecting public-service broadcasting. Nevertheless, it identified continuing concerns over access to public information, protection against abusive lawsuits, particularly domestic strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs), and the safety of journalists.

It also said it had not received sufficient information to assess the broader media reform process initiated following the public inquiry into Caruana Galizia’s assassination, while noting that expectations among journalists and media organisations remained high.

Another central concern was the implementation of recommendations made by the 2021 independent public inquiry, which identified institutional failures and a climate of impunity surrounding the assassination. The delegation said these recommendations, alongside those made by the Venice Commission, GRECO, Moneyval and the European Parliament, remained wholly or partly unimplemented five years later.

Wilmès said the visit had raised fundamental questions about whether journalists investigating corruption would be better protected today, whether credible allegations would be properly investigated and whether justice would be delivered more swiftly. She said the delegation was still far from having clear and reassuring answers.

She stressed that reforms should not become a box-ticking exercise, but needed to address the underlying institutional weaknesses and deliver lasting change.

The delegation also called for stronger checks and balances, urging independent oversight bodies to be given the resources and means to fulfil their mandates. It called for tougher transparency and conflict-of-interest rules, as well as meaningful consultation with civil society and journalists on reforms affecting their rights.

During the visit, MEPs met Prime Minister Robert Abela and senior members of the Cabinet, Opposition Leader Alex Borg, members of Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee, Attorney General Victoria Buttigieg and Police Commissioner Angelo Gafà. They also held discussions with the Chamber of Advocates, the Permanent Commission against Corruption, the Office of the Commissioner for Standards in Public Life and the Financial Intelligence Analysis Unit.

The programme included meetings with members of Caruana Galizia’s family and representatives of the foundation established in her memory, as well as roundtable discussions with journalists and civil society organisations, including Repubblika, Aditus and Occupy Justice.

Wilmès said public confidence in institutions depended on people knowing that justice would be delivered and that the system worked in the public interest. The European Parliament, she added, stood with Caruana Galizia’s family, journalists and civil society in calling for fundamental rights and the rule of law to be upheld in practice.

Filed under Comuniq.EU

More from Comuniq.EU

More →